Last Sunday, as the head (and tail!) of the DC Area Branch of the Committee for Open Debate on the Holocaust (CODOH), I gave a talk entitled “A Call for Open Debate on the Holocaust” at the Arlington (VA) Public Library to a select group of interested parties. Besides myself and my wife, there was an oldish gentleman who happened to be in the library and saw the announcement on the door of the meeting room and came in thinking it sounded interesting; an even older gentleman, an erudite, informed, anti-Zionist, lapsed Jew I’ve known for years; three of my fellow Holocaust “deniers”, one of whom had come all the way from Pennsylvania; two personable Generation Z-ers who displayed a keen, inquisitive, and open-minded attitude in the Q & A; and a spy, who strided into the room with a chip on his shoulder, declined to give his name (as did two others), and took a seat in the far back corner of the room. The audience of eight was disappointing, considering the library is in the heart of the Washington, DC metroplex and many people in this town will sit through some State or Defense Department apparatchik droning on ad nauseum—one platitude, evasion, obfuscation, or lie after another—on some arcane topic, like “The Berlin Process Summit ten years on: Lessons learned and next steps for the WB6”, which you can catch at the Atlantic Council on Oct. 4th, if you have the stomach (and some No-Doz!).
The presentation went as well as can be expected, given that it was the first time I gave the talk, as well as the first time I had ever done a Powerpoint presentation (You can view the slides which accompany my talk here. The discussion which followed was—to my surprise—civil, intelligent, and to-the-point. I’d like to think this was, in part, because of the tone I had established in my talk, and maybe I can take credit for that. In any case, my friend and fellow octogenarian corrected me on my claim that Oscar Schindler was a fictionaI character; one of the Gen Z-ers asked if there was a book which goes into how the myth of gas chambers came to be so universally believed and I directed him to Samuel Crowell’s The Gas Chamber of Sherlock Holmes; and the other Gen Z-er borrowed my copy of the Holocaust Encyclopedia to peruse.
The spy questioned whether the stack of bodies being cremated in the street were really Germans killed in the firebombing of Dresden as their bodies should have already been reduced to ashes (No wonder we deniers are gaining so little traction being up against opponents of such stunning mental acuity!). I suggested not all the dead would have been consumed in the flames—those who died of smoke inhalation or having a building collapse on them, for instance—but I could see he was not convinced. Afterwards I wondered what he was getting at. In my talk I had mentioned that one Jewish organization had assumed (or wanted others to assume) that any pile of smoldering corpses must be Jews and had used the photo in their promotional materials. So, maybe whatever group the spy belonged to makes that claim. Knowing photos—especially ones related to the Holocaust—can be doctored or misinterpreted and having been fooled myself any number of times, I thought I’d better confirm that the photo pictured Dresden, so I got on the Internet and found this:
The statue in the background confirms the macabre scene is in Dresden.
All in all, the event was a good start, which I plan on repeating in the weeks ahead. My schedule for October is:
Oct. 27 (Sunday) 2 – 4 PM MLK Jr. Memorial Library (Room 401-E)
(District of Columbia Public Library)
901 G St. NW, Washington, DC
These events are not sponsored by the libraries listed
_______________________________________________
UPDATE (11/19/24): My speaking tour was a bust. My “Call” echoed through empty halls. In seven events, I had a total audience of 1O (and some were fellow “deniers” already)! Having been a peace activist for two decades in the Washington, DC area I trusted some would have found me an intelligent, informed, fair-minded enough guy to want to know why I held such bizarre views on the Holocaust. Apparently, I flattered myself. I hoped my friendship with one of the leading lights of the antiwar movement, William Blum, author of the seminal work Killing Hope, who once publicized a pamphlet on the topic I had written and made me his health agent in his dying days, would save me from the charge of “antisemitism”, but it didn’t, even in the minds of those who had had the label pinned on themselves in recent times.
I still think exposing the myth of the genocidal gas chambers is important as it can yield valuable insights about our own age, where bogus atrocity stories continue to be one of the most powerful weapons in the arsenal of the warmongers. Their use must be exposed and the perpetrators punished under the charge of Conspiracy to Wage Aggressive War used against the Nazis at Nuremberg.
Moreover, a grave injustice has been and is being done to the Germans, from whom survivors of the mythical gas chambers have received 80 billion dollars over the last 70 years, even their children (and grandchildren!) demanding reparations for the damage done to their psyches, while generations of German kids have had their psyches scarred by being told their fathers and grandfathers committed “the greatest and most horrible crime ever committed in the whole history of the world” (Winston Churchill’s words during the war, though the “most horrible crime” slipped his mind when he wrote his memoirs as he makes no mention of it).
I don’t blame myself entirely for the failure of the project. I know many people stayed away for fear they would be labelled Holocaust “deniers” themselves (they told me so). These staunch Defenders of Free Speech (“I may not agree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it” and all that), worshippers before shrines to Julian Assange, caved in fear of retribution, not from the government, but from the censorious defenders of another faith who, though well organized and powerful, constitute a miniscule percentage of our population. Just think how these Bravehearts would cower before the threat of governmental retribution!
Disappointed in my fellow sapiens, I’m down but not out! I’ve got another project in the works which I will tell you about when it reaches fruition. In the meantime, if there is any group of four or more…hell, ANYONE in the Washington, DC area who would be willing to listen to my presentation in private, I’d be happy to oblige. Just send me a note (kiaskfm@verizon.net).
It’s easier to fool people than to convince them they’ve been fooled– Mark Twain (or someone like that)
I’m known to family and friends and beyond as a Holocaust Denier.* How I acquired that slanderous epithet (one step below pedophile, just half a step above serial killer in the scale of public opprobrium) is sort of humorous.
One day in 2009 I got a call from the president of the citizens association in my hometown, Reston, Virginia. Founded in 1963, Reston bills itself as America’s first planned community and has a historical marker to prove it! At the time, Reston was owned by Gulf Oil and the only Reston-specific entity resembling a governmental body was the Reston Homeowners Association, the majority of whose board members were selected by the corporation (Despite its small-town boosterism, Reston has no town-granting charter from the state and is simply a part of Fairfax County, a suburb of Washington, DC). So, some concerned residents, leery of self-centered corporate greed, founded the Reston Citizens Association (RCA) to protect the interests of the “townspeople”.
The RCA was having its annual election and they needed to fill two seats on the board. Normally, incumbent board members run for a new term and are automatically re-elected, but one member was retiring from the board and they were having trouble finding someone to run in his place. I presented myself at the time as an expert on the fate of the world (see my 2004 tome, The Ethic of Zero Growth) but wasn’t doing anything concrete to advance the cause of all humanity. So, in the spirit of “Think globally, act locally”, when the president of the RCA asked if I would be a candidate, I put my hat in the ring.
One of the board members, a Jewish lady, knew of me from my public access television show, Worlddocs, on which I aired documentaries on controversial issues in international affairs. One of the films was on the Holocaust, as seen through the eyes of a so-called Holocaust denier (The station had tried to squelch that episode and it cost them $6000 in lawyer’s fees to find out they really shouldn’t do that). Ms. Defender of the Faith—we’ll call her “Golda”—was aghast at the thought of sitting next to me at board meetings and initiated a campaign against me. This led to an article on me on the front page of the Metro section of The Washington Post.
Golda convinced the retiring board member to run as a write-in candidate (it was too late to run officially) and started calling around telling Restonians not to vote for me but instead write in the incumbent’s name.
The election was held during a town festival and Golda showed up at the RCA’s polling station sporting a sandwich board saying, “Don’t vote for the Holocaust Denier”. I got a call from a board member who didn’t care for Golda and he encouraged me to go to the festival to defend myself. So, there we were: Golda with her sign, pointing at me as she talked with passers-by, and me explaining myself to any passer-by open-minded enough to talk with me. At one point, our congressman, whom I knew from my TV show, passed by with a hesitant look on his face but had the decency to say “Hello”.
Midway through the polling, Golda realized it was not enough for people just to vote for the write-in candidate; they had to vote for the other board member who was running as well, or I would win as I had garnered some votes in the pre-election, mail-in balloting before my scurrilous character came to light. So, Golda started frantically calling around to spread the word. In the end, I lost in a landslide: 1157 to 23 (I should have at least gotten a thank-you note from the RCA as their elections usually only garner 300 or so votes). I went home bitterly disappointed that I wouldn’t have to attend RCA board meetings, poured myself a drink, and laughed myself silly. (The next day I got a call from the RCA president who said she knew I wasn’t a bad person, but “please don’t come to any of our meetings”.)
In the following years I enhanced my reputation as a “denier” with articles on the Holocaust published on alt news sites, then on the blog I initiated in 2017. My efforts to enlighten the benighted have echoed with a resounding thud, and I don’t quite understand why. I think most people would be astounded to learn there were no genocidal gas chambers, as I contend, given all those Academy Award-winning movies portraying such. Wouldn’t you be? So, it seems to me if people who know my contention respected me as an intelligent, knowledgeable, fair-minded guy, they’d want to know why I believe such nonsense. But in 20 years of Holocaust bubble-popping, I can count the number of people—including family members—who have queried me about this on one hand and still have fingers left over. I’m apparently not so impressive—intellectually or personally—as I assume, despite my Phi Beta Kappa key from Dartmouth and my ready smile.
Having been unsuccessful in borrowing any ears, in 2016 I put together a Powerpoint presentation on my idée fixe and rented a space to expound on my beliefs. One person, a friend, showed up. Ever the optimist, now I am doing it again. Two things related to the conflict in Gaza encourage me to believe I will get better attendance this time. The first is the denigration of the term anti-Semitic. At a time when so much as complaining that the bagel you bought at a Starbucks was stale can get you charged with anti-Semitism, maybe the term has been so abused that some might question whether it applies even to Holocaust deniers. Secondly, the horror of the slaughter in Gaza has made it socially acceptable to critique some Jews (Zionists) and maybe the same can be said of those Jews (and their Gentile parrots) who have turned a genuine tragedy into a laugh fest (see my blog posting “The Hilarious Holocaust”).
You might wonder why I consider it worthwhile to debunk Holocaust myths 80 years after the fact. It’s because the bogus atrocity story is one of the most powerful weapons in the arsenal of the warmongers and the Holocaust is the example par excellence. We have a current example in the sexual assaults the Israelis claim HAMAS fighters committed (In a Human Rights Watch report on the conflict no such assaults are mentioned because the Israelis failed to provide any evidence of such). If the debunking of the Holocaust story caused you to never again believe any atrocity story, even the real ones, it would be better than to continue to fall for bogus atrocity stories, as so many do.
So, if you are in the DC area on Sunday, Sept. 29th, please attend the presentation at the Arlington Public Library (This event is not sponsored by the library) at 1 PM. If you can’t make it, here are the slides of the Powerpoint presentation I will be making: Presentation – current.pdf are self-explanatory, but not all; so, if you want to hear the commentary that goes with them, you’ll just have to arrange for me to speak in your area.
————————————-
* Some Holocaust Deniers prefer the term “revisionist”, “critic”, “skeptic”, and the like, but I purposely call myself a denier, so that when I make my profession of faith (“I believe that during World War II masses of Jews were uprooted from their homes and confined in camps where they died in droves”), some will question why I am called a denier and turn their contempt on those who use the cheap, sleazy, rhetorical trick of labelling their opponents “deniers”, so that the easily intimidated will not even listen to what the so-called “deniers” have to say.
Israel Without Zionism: A Plan for Peace in the Middle East is a book by Uri Avnery, a member of the Israeli Knesset (parliament). Avnery begins his discourse with a little biography: how his family presciently migrated to Palestine from Germany in 1933, the struggle they faced making it in their new home, and his own struggle learning the everyday Hebrew being resurrected there. The violence between Arabs and Jews which wracked the country in the 1930s (despite the two people’s common goal to drive out the British) led to his joining the Zionist militant group Irgun. In his enlistment interview, when asked if he hated Arabs he responded, “No, I can fight the British without hating the Arabs”*—the wrong answer, but he still was sworn into “the organization” (meaning of Irgun). He describes the joy, thrill, and honor he felt, as a fifteen-year-old, plotting attacks against the British.
In a youthful stance which would prove lifelong, Avnery opposed the dismemberment of Palestine as set out in the UN’s Partition Plan in 1947, advocating instead for “One country, from the sea to the desert”. The new state which came out of Israel’s War of Liberation (in which he was wounded) left him nonplussed as its leaders failed to address the main issue, in his opinion: how to achieve peace with the Arabs. When the war was over, he advocated allowing the hundreds of thousands of Palestinians who had fled the fighting to return to their homes, a sticking point which remains unresolved to this day.
The raison d’etre of Israel, according to Avnery, is the Zionist dream of an “ingathering of the Exiles”, i.e., settlement in Israel of all the world’s Jews, all 15 (or so) million of them. It’s this goal which makes Zionism “expansionist by nature”. Where are all those Jews doing aliyah (migrating to Israel) supposed to settle? There’s clearly not enough room within the 75% of Palestine occupied by Israel in 1948, even within the expanded territory Israel occupies today. Hence, the constant drive to usurp more Arab land.
So far, that ingathering has not occurred, more Jews living today someplace other than Israel than those living in the Promised Land (8 million vs. 7 million). Jews may chant : ”Next Year in Jerusalem” at Passover seders, but the wish has lost all but symbolic meaning in an age when any Jew anyplace in the world can be in Jerusalem in a matter of hours. It’s sort of like the line beloved by many Texans, “Come and take it”, the defiant response given in 1835 by independence-seeking Texans when ordered to return a cannon lent to them by the Mexican government. My brother in Dallas flies a flag with those words on it, but he has no cannon, loaded and cocked, ready to be fired on any Mexican who steps onto his property.
Symbolic of the antiquated status of the Zionist program, Avnery maintains, is the attitude of native-born Israelis towards their coreligionists elsewhere. To the Israelis, they are Jews; whereas, they themselves are Hebrews. To a certain extent, Israelis look down on foreign Jews, as many American Jews learn on tours of their refuge of last resort. This experience reflects a reality which should not be overlooked; namely, that there are now 3rd and 4th generation Israelis, i.e., native-born Israelis whose great- and great-great-grandfather was the first of the family to disembark in Haifa. Israel has come to constitute a new nation, a nation like any other, with its own flag, its own institutions, its own culture, its own interests, and its own future. In Avnery’s words, “the sons and daughters of Zionism are indeed a new nation, not just another part of world Jewry which happens to live in Palestine” and “does not include a Jew in Brooklyn, Paris or Bucharest, much as he may sympathize with our country and feel an affinity for it”.
In light of the national identity fostered in Israel over the country’s eight decades of existence, “Not one single Israeli, and certainly not I”, Avnery states categorically, “would ever agree to any solution which does not recognize the existence of Israel as a sovereign state”. In line with this conviction, Avnery advocated up to his death in 2018 for the two-state solution to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. I’m surprised at this, as I think the settlements Israel has built in the land they occupy in the West Bank, the Golan Heights, and, perhaps to come, Gaza has foreclosed the possibility of Israel ever accepting the two-state solution if it means abandoning those settlements. So I remain committed to the one-state solution. What the Arabs proposed since way back when the UN first debated how to resolve the Palestine Problem is still, I believe, the best option; namely, the creation of a democratic, secular, binational state in all of Palestine. But Avnery’s contention that the Israelis have forged a new nation, a nation which, if it follows Avnery’s advice to “take a positive attitude toward the national aspirations of the Arab peoples”, can live in peace with its neighbors causes me pause to reexamine whether the one-state solution is any more possible or advisable than the two-state.
Uri Avnery published Israel Without Zionism in 1968, when the Israelis were flush with pride in their remarkable victory in the Six Day War. Not surprisingly, his appeal did not generate great enthusiasm amongst his fellow countrymen. The party he had founded in 1965, HaOlam HaZeh, succeeded in increasing its representation in the Knesset from one to two (out of 120) in 1969, but that marked the high point for the party. Avnery continued being a thorn in the side of the Zionists for the rest of his life, in 1993 founding the Gush Shalom (Peace Bloc) movement, which continues to promote his stance on Zionism. May they succeed where he failed, so that the warning Avnery voiced in Israel without Zionism does not come to pass: “If the vicious circle is not broken, and broken soon, it will lead, with the certainty of a Greek tragedy, toward a holocaust that will bury Tel Aviv and Cairo, Damascus and Jerusalem.” (and Washington and New York? – KM)
========================================= * Avnery points out that, contrary to popular belief today, “Nothing like European anti-Semitism ever existed in the Arab world prior to the events which created the vicious circle”, echoing a fellow countryman and noted historian, who states in his book, Heritage: Civilization and the Jews, that, in general, Jews have fared better under Muslim rule than Christian. The historian: Abba Eban, onetime Israeli foreign Minister.
** In the aftermath of the 1982 Israeli-promoted massacre of Palestinians in two refugee camps in Lebanon, Avnery made an observation that sheds light on the massacre taking place in Gaza today:
I will tell you something about the Holocaust. It would be nice to believe that people who have undergone suffering have been purified by suffering. But it’s the opposite, it makes them worse. It corrupts. There is something in suffering that creates a kind of egoism. Herzog [the Israeli president at the time] was speaking at the site of the concentration camp at Bergen-Belsen but he spoke only about the Jews. How could he not mention that others – many others – had suffered there? Sick people, when they are in pain, cannot speak about anyone but themselves. And when such monstrous things have happened to your people, you feel nothing can be compared to it. You get a moral “power of attorney”, a permit to do anything you want – because nothing can compare to what has happened to us. This is a moral immunity which is very clearly felt in Israel.
Last Saturday, my wife and I drove down to the tiny hamlet of Clifton, Virginia, pop. 243. The town has such a pastoral setting you might think it’s somewhere in the Shenandoah Valley. In fact, it’s in Fairfax County, Virginia, a county of over a million people just across the Potomac River from Washington, DC. As suburban sprawl crept toward the town in the 1970s (about the same time Clifton gained some notoriety as the haunt of the Bunny Man), the town council passed an ordinance that only one building could be placed on 5-acre lots, resulting in the township being graced with attractive, wealth-flaunting mansions surrounded by acres of perfectly manicured lawn.
Back during the Civil War, when it was known as Devereux Station, Clifton was something of a railroad hub. Trains still run right across Main Street and we were lucky enough to have one roar through while we were enjoying an ice cream cone at the appropriately named Ice Cream Depot. The moment brought to mind one of my favorite folk songs, “Freight Train, Freight Train”, which I immediately began singing, to my wife’s embarrassment (In veritate, the train was an AMTRAK passenger train, not a freight). I couldn’t remember all the lyrics; so, when I got home, I did a search on the internet.
I never did find the lyrics per se, but it turns out the song has an interesting history. It was written by Elizabeth Cotten, born in Chapel Hill, North Carolina in 1893. She wrote it when she was a teenager, singing it just for family and friends. Later in life, she was working in a department store in Washington, DC and helped a lost little boy find his parents. The parents turned out to be Pete and Toshi Seeger, the patron saints of American folk music. The Seeger’s hired Miss Cotten as a domestic, and—thanks to that fortuitous encounter—one of the country’s most inventive guitarists was saved from obscurity as Seeger promoted her music.
Thanks to Seeger’s efforts, “Freight Train” entered the repertoire of a host of folksingers, including Joan Baez, Peter, Paul & Mary, and supposedly The Beatles (though there is no recording of them singing it). In 2022, Cotten was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame—belatedly, as she had died in 1987. You can hear her explaining her creative, Cotten-picking style and singing “Freight Train” here.
While many have been infatuated with the catchy tune, Cotten’s lyrics have not enjoyed as much popularity. Consequently, others have amended, expanded, or just ignored her lyrics and come up with their own (No wonder I couldn’t find the official lyrics). Since others had tried it, I thought I would give it a shot, too, borrowing some verses, changing others, and adding some of my own. Here’s what I came up with:
Ballad of the Happy Hobo
Freight train, freight train, goin’ so fast
Freight train, freight train, goin’ so fast
I don’t care what train I’m on
As long as it keeps rollin’ on
Ridin’ the rails is the life for me
Heart on fire and a mind carefree
Please don’t tell what train I’m on
So they won’t know where I’ve gone
One more place I’d like to be
One more sight I’d like to see
To watch the haze on the Blue Ridge rise
As I ride old Number 9
Freight train, freight train, comin’ round the bend
Freight train, freight train, gone again
One of these days turn that train around
Take me back to my hometown
When I’m dead in that last nap
No more good times to recap
Carve on the tombstone at my head
“Rode the rails where’er they led”
Pick a spot and bury me deep
Down by the tracks off some Main Street
So I can hear old Number 9
As she goes roarin’ by
I’ve been told I have a nice singing voice, so I thought I would sing my rendition myself. You can listen to it here and judge for yourself.
(Blame whoever told me I have a nice singing voice. I do!)
A year after the 1861 Battle of Aquia Creek, the Confederates abandoned their positions at the juncture of Aquia Creek with the Potomac River. Union forces then briefly occupied the area and thousands of slaves fled their plantations for Aquia Landing and were transported on boats to Washington, DC. This is the story of one of those slaves:
I had just turned 16 when I was selected to leave the slave quarters and work in the kitchen of The Big House. I wondered why I had been chosen. I suspected it was because I had the lightest skin of all the girls. Maybe because I was also the prettiest.
I quickly realized how privileged I was to be working in the mansion. The work was easy and the food was better. I had a room on the top floor with a comfortable bed—even sheets, a dresser for my things, plenty of light through the windows, and—best of all—a mirror in which I spent a shameful amount of time admiring myself (I had yet to learn that beauty is both a blessing and a curse for a woman). I missed my parents and sharing that dank, dirt-floored, crammed cabin with them, but I had no desire to be sent back to that life.
So, I behaved as I was taught. I was respectful towards the Master and his Missus, calling them “Sir” and “Ma’am”, prompt in responding to their wishes, and diligent as I could be in my labors. I was also polite to the black butler, though I didn’t like or respect him. He was very haughty with the field workers, calling them “lazy”, “stupid”, “filthy”, and the like, while being… well, slavishly obsequious with the white folks.
One day, after I had finished a pork chop he had given me that the Missus had not touched at dinner, the butler asked me to come into the pantry. I thought maybe he had more food for me (I was always hungry). This surprised me as he usually kept any extra food for himself.
“Did you enjoy the pork chop?”, he asked, “Would you like to show your appreciation for my kindness?”
Nodding noncommittedly to both queries, I watched in confusion as he started to unbuckle his belt. Suddenly, a conversation I had overheard where the older girls were talking about some act related to sex. I wasn’t sure exactly what it was; but, as the butler lowered his pants, I felt like I was about to find out. Once before, the Master had taken me into the pantry and started loosening his belt, but he hadn’t gotten any further before the Missus, looking for some jam, opened the door. She let out a scream loud enough for the neighbors a mile away to hear, then that demure, frills-and-lace, Southern belle stormed away directing the vilest invectives I’d ever heard at her husband–who never again took me into the pantry. (Years later, when I’d learned more about sex on the plantations, the horrifying realization came to me that the Master may have been about to engage in a carnal act with his own daughter!)
Pulling his penis out of his drawers, the butler said, “Suck on this.”
I told him I didn’t know what he meant, to which he responded, “Put it in your mouth.”
I explained that I’d never done this before and pleaded with him not to make me do it.
“Do it!”, he commanded in his harshest tone.
I knew he had it in his power to have me sent back to the fields—maybe after a good whipping—so I did as he demanded. As his penis swelled in my mouth, I imagined cutting the thing off and stuffing it in his mouth, wiping that smug, self-satisfied grin off his face.
When it was over, he zipped up his pants and resumed his butlering duties without so much as a “Thank you”, while I remained in the pantry, in tears over what had just happened. His disgusting fluid still in my mouth, I spat it out onto my apron. Just then the Missus summoned me, so I regained my composure as best I could, and responded “Coming, Ma’am”.
All day long I was near suicidal with depression and self-shame. I wanted revenge on that domineering, selfish man so bad but couldn’t show it. That night when he came into the kitchen to get something while I was slicing carrots, when he knelt down to tie his shoe, I began stabbing him in the back with the knife in my hand. After five or six stabs, he slunk to the floor. I turned him over, slashed open his pants, yanked out his penis, and cut it off. I stuffed it in his mouth, saying “Suck on this, bastard!” Then I grabbed a loaf of bread off the kitchen table and ran towards the woods.
It wasn’t long before someone (I’m not sure who) came upon the body, and even less time for them to figure out who had killed him, what with the bloody apron on the floor. They guessed correctly I had fled to the woods. I might as well have thrown myself into a briar patch! When I was a child they had often sent me into the woods to gather mushrooms and I knew all the trails, some known only to the deer.
Once I reached the creek, I walked down it so the dogs couldn’t follow my track, surviving on the bread and some blackberries I found in the woods. After a night and a day of walking, or better wading, I reached the mouth of the creek. Some runaway slaves were about to be taken across the Potomac to the North by Union soldiers and I just had time to hop on board, exhausted but happier than I’d ever been.
As we crossed the river the sun was just making its appearance on the eastern horizon. I’d seen many beautiful sunrises before, but this one seemed special: glorious shades of pink coloring fluffy white clouds pierced by shafts of bright light, with the orange sky gradually turning to a deep blue as the rising sun—yellowing as it rose—began its daily journey around the earth. The scene struck me as almost biblical, heralding the dawning of a new day and, for me, a new life, a life to be lived in the sweetest, noblest, most human way: in freedom.
_____________________________________________
As related by Bess Lankford of New Hope, Pennsylvania (born on the Aquia Creek Plantation in Stafford County, Virginia in 1846) on the occasion of her 90th birthday to those of her grandchildren who had reached maturity.
“Severe Weather Alert!” screamed the Weather Channel day after frightening day as tornadoes wreaked havoc across the country in May. As is my custom when I hear of an “unprecedented” weather phenomenon, I checked out the precedents, i.e., the historical record, to see if the event really was unprecedented since I usually find hyperbolic outbursts over some weather event tied to global warming overblown), To my surprise, May’s tornadoes really were extreme.
Disappointed that the data did not support my skepticism about global warming alarmism, I could take some solace in the fact that prior to May the number of tornadoes had been quite average. Also, looked at over a longer time frame, this year’s count was way exceeded by that 13 years ago (2011):
Moreover, the data does not support the global warming alarmist claim that the frequency of severe tornadoes is increasing:
If I were to encounter an article entitled “A Profession of Faith on…”, I probably wouldn’t read it—even if it supported my personal beliefs—as I would assume it to be long on opinion, short on facts. I want to know the facts; I can form my own opinion. If you are like me, you might want to stop reading here as I am about to make a profession of faith. (If you do read on, you can learn some of the facts behind my opinion by consulting postings to this blog 13, 20, 24, 25, 32, 40, 62, 79, 98.)
I believe the earth is getting warmer (who doesn’t?*). I believe the Greenhouse Effect is good science and so carbon emissions are a factor in the warming, though it may not be the only factor or even a major one. I believe it is good that we look for alternative energy sources like wind and solar**, regardless of whether this leads to reduced carbon emissions, because the bonanza of cheap energy we have enjoyed from the exploitation of fossil fuels is coming to an end.*** To believe wind, solar, and the like can replace fossil fuels entirely is a fool’s errand. If Global Warming is being hyped—and I believe it is—our delusion is being fostered by those who promote the hype instead of forcing us to face the truth.****
We, like all species, thrive and multiply according to the amount of energy available to us. Barring a new source of energy equivalent to fossil fuels being found or devised (hydrogen, nuclear fusion, etc.), we must necessarily experience a decline in our global standard of living. We can plan for this***** or just watch it happen—so gradual as to be imperceptible, but with increasing chaos and suffering.
————————–
* One of the best known “deniers” maintains a monthly calculation of the mean global temperature based on satellite data, which posits a warming of 1.5˚ C per century.
** Switching to electric cars may not be such a good idea, however, as many more power plants would have to be built to charge all those batteries, and, as the graph below suggests, the most likely fuel to be used in these plants is coal, a notorious carbon emitter:
Unlike oil and natural gas, there is plenty of coal still left—hundreds of years worth–and it remains easily exploitable. And it’s the cheapest fuel available.
*** Regarding petroleum, we are not running out of the black gold yet (half of what was in the ground originally is still there), but it is becoming increasingly expensive to exploit (i.e. the Energy Returned on Energy Invested (ERoEI) is decreasing)—think hydraulic fracturing.
**** It’s inexplicable to me why there is so much clamor over global warming but so much less over an issue which is more immediate, more susceptible to human amelioration, and more of an existential threat: nuclear war. If you are ready to take action on this danger, there are several events surrounding the NATO Summit in Washington, DC on July 6th and 7th you might attend or watch online:
Saturday, July 6, 2024
No to NATO – Alternative Summit, 9:30 AM – 5:30 PM, at St. Mark’s Church Capitol Hill, 3rd Ave. and A St. SE, Washington, DC (https://nonatoyespeace.org/)
***** For instance, by reducing the number of cars on the road and/or the number of miles driven; the same for ships (less transnational cargo) and planes (fewer flights). Also, by building more compact housing and fewer mega-mansions.
While you’re celebrating the 80th anniversary of D-Day, allow me to tell you another war story you’ve probably never heard (I graduated Phi Beta Kappa with a major in American History from an Ivy League school and I never had!). You may find it doesn’t fill you with the same patriotic pride as the Allied landing, but it will provide a fuller understanding of how unheroic war can be, and that’s something we all should face.
“The Laconia Incident”, as the story is known, begins with a German submarine, U-156, sinking the British passenger ship RMS Laconia, off the coast of Africa in September 1942. Though a passenger ship, the Laconia was a legitimate target according to the rules of war as it was armed and carrying troops. On board were 463 officers and crew, 87 civilians, 286 British soldiers, 1,793 Italian prisoners, and 103 Polish soldiers.
As the ship was sinking, most of the passengers made it into lifeboats, except the Italians, who were trapped in locked cargo holds. Still, most of them made it out as well through smashed hatches or ventilation shafts, only to be shot, bayoneted, or have their hands hacked off when they tried to climb into the lifeboats. The blood attracted sharks who feasted on the living and the dead.
When the submarine surfaced, expecting to find just a few dozen of the ship’s officers alive, they were shocked to see 2000 survivors floundering in the lifeboats or in the water. The Germans immediately commenced a rescue operation, securing four of the lifeboats to the sub and loading her deck with those plucked from the waves. The captain of the sub broadcast an uncoded message in English calling for any ships in the area to come to the rescue, promising not to attack them so long as they were not themselves attacked. He also had a large Red Cross flag draped over the deck, an internationally recognized sign that the sub was engaged in a rescue operation. Informed of the situation, Admiral Dönitz, head of German submarine operations, ordered seven U-boats to proceed to the site of the sinking to assist U-156.
The British thought the captain’s message was a ruse meant to attract Allied ships into range, and they passed their suspicion on to the American military, who dispatched a bomber from their base on Ascension Island to check out the situation. Despite a captured British officer radioing a message to the pilot of the plane that Allied personnel and civilians, including women and children, were onboard the sub, the bomber made four bomb runs. The bombs failed to release on the first three runs, but two bombs were successfully dropped on the fourth. The crew of the bomber reported they had sunk the German sub (and were awarded medals on that basis), when in fact they had missed the sub but sunk two of the survivor-packed lifeboats. (No doubt the medals are proudly displayed each Memorial Day by the crew’s descendants, unaware of the less-than-heroic full story,). The sub immediately submerged but did so slowly so as to give the prisoners on deck a chance as they were forced back into the water.
Most of the survivors were soon picked up by Vichy French ships (France then having a government which adopted a neutral position on the war), but two lifeboats had separated from the others and made for the coast of Africa. They were not picked up till a month later, only 20 of the 120 in the boats being still alive. All in all, of the Laconia’s original complement of 2,741, 1,083 survived (most of the dead were Italian POWs).*
But the story of the Laconia does not end there. Up until that point, it was common for U-boats to assist torpedoed survivors with food, water, and medical care, but in response to U-156 being fired upon while engaged in a rescue operation, Admiral Dönitz, head of German submarine operations, issued an order, the Laconia Order, which prohibited U-boats from attempting to rescue survivors. To appease the consciences of his sailors, Dönitz appended this reminder to the order: “Be harsh. Remember that the enemy has no regard for women and children when bombing German cities!.” Nonetheless, even after the order was given, U-boats still occasionally provided aid to survivors.
For issuing the Laconia Order, Dönitz was prosecuted at Nuremberg, but the prosecution’s case fell apart when the full story of the Laconia came out, especially after Admiral Nimitz, commander of the US Pacific Fleet, testified—to his credit—that the United States had practiced “unrestricted submarine warfare” (a policy allowing submarines to sink merchant ships without warning) from the first day the United States entered the war. No wonder Supreme Court Chief Justice Harlan Stone disparaged the Nuremberg Tribunal as a “high-grade lynching party”. Makes you wonder what other war crimes the Nazi’s may have been unjustly accused of (e.g., gas chambers?).**
Maybe if we memorialized the Laconia Incident the way we do D-Day, it would help lift the blood-red fog draped—intentionally and unintentionally—over war’s realities—so the heavenly blue sky of peace can shine through.
**********
* If you are gloating over the Germans sinking a ship carrying their own allies, remember the case of the Shinyō Maru, a Japanese ship carrying 750 Allied prisoners which was sunk in 1944 by an American submarine, only 82 POWs surviving. Symbolic of the fog thrown over unfortunate events like this by those promoting warrior zealotry, the crew of the submarine was not informed the ship they sank was carrying Allied prisoners until after the war was over.
** I met a Czech woman recently to whom I expressed my admiration for the beauty of Prague, “The City of 100 Spires”, and remarked how lucky it was that it wasn’t bombed during the Second World War. She explained that Hitler spared the city to show that the Nazis were not heartless barbarians. Not so with the allies, who firebombed another of Europe’s most beautiful cities, Dresden—killing 100,000—though the attack served no military purpose other than to slow the Soviet advance on Berlin (They got there first anyway). Churchill confided in his diary that, had Britain lost the war, he would have been hung as a war criminal for Dresden alone (No idea whether Eisenhower was equally honest with himself). Makes me wonder whether it was the good guys who won the war. (Frankly, I don’t think there were any good guys… or bad guys, just people like you and me caught up, by circumstance or choice, in a horrible, perplexing situation where they strived to do what was required of them and morality was obscured by the necessities of the moment).
(The facts cited here come from the Warren Commission Report, henceforth referred to as “WCR”, and the book History Will Not Absolve Us by E. Martin Schotz, henceforth referred to as “Schotz”)
I was in Dallas recently and used the opportunity to visit the Texas School Book Depository from whose sixth-floor window Lee Harvey Oswald reputedly shot President Kennedy on November 22, 1963. I learned something I hadn’t known before which has enabled me to pin down who actually did the shooting. What I learned was that the building’s two freight elevators were stuck at the fifth and sixth floors at the time of the shooting. That got me to speculating on how the assassin—whoever he might be—descended from the “sniper’s nest” on the sixth floor.
First, let’s eliminate Oswald as a suspect. The fact that the best marksmen in the world have been unable to duplicate the feat Oswald supposedly accomplished—firing three shots on target in just over 5 seconds using a second-rate rifle with a misaligned telescopic sight (Schotz, p. 110)—proves if Oswald was the shooter, he wasn ‘t the only one (The lone gunman theory can be resurrected if it is assumed a more sophisticated rifle than Oswald’s, an automatic, was used, as the 3-shots-in-5+-seconds feat then becomes more plausible). That Oswald was not even one of the assassins is attested to by Dallas Police Chief Jesse Curry who, belatedly, came to believe in Oswald’s innocence because the test administered on Oswald’s right cheek showed no presence of gunpowder residue, i.e., Oswald had not fired his Italian carbine, or any rifle, that day (Schotz, p. 232).
Further proof, for me, that Oswald could not have been the shooter is based on what I had learned about the Depository’s elevators. Their being on the fifth and sixth floor at the time of the shooting set me to wondering how Oswald had made it to the second floor in time to be seen by Dallas patrolman Marion Baker less than a minute and a half after his final shot? According to the Commission, that first shooting occurred at 12:30 PM (WCR, pp. 48-49). Baker, accompanied by the building’s superintendent, Roy Truly, was racing up the stairs (since the elevators weren’t available) when he saw Oswald walking toward the lunchroom (The commission estimates this was a minute and 20 seconds after the shots were fired, WCR, p. 152). When Truly identified Oswald as a Depository employee, the two continued the climb to the roof, from where Baker thought the shots had been fired (WCR, p. 151-152). Oswald proceeded to the lunchroom, where, apparently in no hurry, he bought a Coke at a vending machine, and proceeded to exit by the building’s front door.
Oswald’s Olympian sprint down the stairs (so quiet no one either heard or saw him) was tested by the Commission, which found the time required to go from the sniper’s nest in the southeast corner of the building, down an aisle along the east wall, place a rifle near where Oswald’s rifle was found, walk along the north wall to the stairwell in the northwest corner of the building, go down four flights of stairs, and walk into the second-floor lunchroom was 1 minute and 18 seconds at a normal pace (Baker, in his affidavit, stated Oswald was not out of breath when accosted, WCR, Vol. 4, p. 248). The horizontal distance traversed was about 125 feet along the walls, plus the distance to where the rifle was hidden, the 20 or so feet of the four landings, and the 25 or so feet from the stairwell to the lunchroom, for a total of around 180 feet. The vertical distance was four flights of stairs, each floor having a height over 10 feet.
I challenge the Commission’s timing. Try it yourself and see what you come up with. Note that the Commission’s run included placing a rifle nearwhere Oswald’s was found, not where it was found. This photo of Oswald’s rifle in situ suggests it was more than a momentary pause to place the rifle amongst all those boxes.
Moreover, it’s not clear if the test included being impeded by boxes, as this photo suggests probably was the case:
If the time cited by the Commission is a gross underestimate, particularly for someone who was 5’9” and maybe not in the best shape, Oswald cannot be the shooter. Oswald was just the “patsy”, as he claimed in his one public statement. A retesting of the time it takes to get from the sniper’s nest to the lunchroom is called for.
If Oswald wasn’t the shooter, who was? To frame Oswald as the presicide, there would have had to be a handler. I think this person would necessarily have to be an employee of the Depository, and perhaps live in the same boarding house in South Dallas as Oswald, in order to perform the tasks required of him:
Obtain the three shell casings found in the “sniper’s nest” (Perhaps by expressing an interest in purchasing Oswald’s rifle and borrowing it to test it);
Arrange for Oswald to bring the rifle to the Depository on that fateful day by setting that date for the handler to purchase the rifle;
See that Oswald was in the depository (not outside watching the parade) at the time of the shooting but not in the presence of anyone who knew him (and could be his alibi);
Get himself up to the sniper’s nest without being seen, having planted Oswald’s rifle and his own more sophisticated gun on the sixth floor beforehand (the only evidence tying Oswald’s rifle to the shots on the motorcade are two bullet fragments, found in the Presidential car after it had been returned to Washington (WCR, p. 76), so damaged the Commission admitted they couldn’t be sure whether they were fragments from two bullets or parts of a single bullet (WCR, p. 85));
See that the elevator was on the sixth floor with its safety gate downto prevent anyone from coming up to the 6th floor while the assassination was in progress, as the elevator was inoperable when the safety gate was down (WCR, p. 143);
Get himself down from the 6th floor without being seen after disassembling his gun and hiding it in one of the many boxes, which he had plenty of time to accomplish as the sniper’s nest was not found till half an hour after the shooting (WCR, p. 79).
So who was this handler/shooter? He would be the person among the Depository’s employees who
Was hired only a couple of months before the assassination (Oswald started working at the Depository a month before.);
Was not in the presence of any people who knew him (e.g., other employees) at the time of the shooting;
Used an assumed name;
Had a connection with anti-Castro Cubans.
Find the employee who fits that description and you have your assassin.
Why is it important to learn the full story behind Kennedy’s assassination? By failing to provide air support for the anti-Castro Cubans who tried to invaded their homeland in 1961, by negotiating a reciprocal agreement with the Soviets during the 1962 Cuban Missile Criss under which the Soviets removed their missiles from Cuba and we removed ours from Turkey instead of just issuing an ultimatum to the Soviets, for daring to enlighten Americans to the fact the Soviet Union had experienced a loss in the Second World War “equivalent to the devastation of this country, east of Chicago” (Schotz, p. 44), for committing his administration “to build a world at peace where the weak are safe and the strong are just” (Schotz, p. 49) Kennedy had incurred the animosity of the deeply entrenched, bellicose, “If you want peace, prepare for war” faction of our power elite—the “military-industrial complex” Eisenhower warned us about. Whoever was behind it, Kennedy’s assassination was a victory for these hegemony-pursuing world-beaters, restoring them to dominance in the determination of our foreign policy, a dominance they enjoy to this day.
What a different world it might have been had Kennedy lived! Our relations with Cuba might have been normalized decades ago, our incipient intervention in Vietnam might not have led to all-out war, and a 40-year Cold War which saw resources wasted on both sides building an arsenal of 30,000 nuclear bombs might have been avoided. We might now live in a world at peace instead of the perilous world of today, which threatens our very existence. By discrediting the hawks of his day and, by extension, their successors in our own time, the truth of the tragedy that occurred on November 22, 1963 might save us from World War Final.
UPDATE (5/10/24): Turns out I don’t know who shot JFK. I did further research and learned that all the Depository employees had alibis (i.e., were with others or seen by others at the time of the shooting) except two: Jack Dougherty and Oswald. Dougherty was thoroughly investigated by the Commission, so I, like them, exonerate him; and Oswald, as you know, I argue didn’t do it.
My research wasn’t entirely in vain as it did yield some additional information exonerating Oswald. One gem was truly bizarre. A couple of minutes after leaving the Depository, Oswald boarded a bus as he fled to his rooming-house in South Dallas. Beyond belief, a lady Oswald had rented a room from a month earlier was on that bus and recognized him. This unbelievable coincidence (and let’s leave it at that, my fellow conspiracists) pinpoints when Oswald realized he had been framed. She described him as looking like “a maniac… he looked so bad in his face, and his face was so distorted” (WCR, p. 159). This just minutes after Oswald, confronted by a policeman in the Depository’s lunchroom, “seemed calm”. According to the officer, “he didn’t change his expression one bit. He didn’t seem to be excited or overly afraid of anything… I cannot recall any change in expression of any kind on his face” (WCR, p. 152). If Oswald had ice water of such glacial proportions in his veins as to remain calm when accosted by a policeman with his gun drawn two minutes after he had assassinated the President of the United States, the ice had melted by the time he boarded that bus looking panic-stricken. Sometime between stopping to buy a Coke on his way out of the Depository and when he boarded the bus, it dawned on him he was the “patsy”.
There is one other remarkably fortuitous encounter which tends to exonerate Oswald; namely, that chance glimpse of Oswald heading for the lunchroom by the patrolman as he ran up the stairs, thinking the shots had been fired from the building’s roof. The Commission concluded that it took the officer between one minute fifteen seconds and one minute thirty seconds to motor over to the Depository, ascend to the second floor, and espy Oswald (WCR, p. 152).
As I suggested you do in my original posting, I tested how long it would have taken Oswald to leave the sniper’s nest after firing his last shot, cross the floor to the stairwell, descend to the second floor, and cross from the bottom of the stairs to the lunchroom. Here’s my calculation:
(1) Time for Oswald to walk from the sniper’s nest in the SE corner of the 6th floor, proceed down the east, then the north, walls (each side being 97 feet) at a brisk pace (3 mph) to the stairwell in the NW corner: 45 seconds;
(2) Time to hide gun near the stairs (10 seconds);
(3) Time to descend four flights of stairs, each floor being 12 feet in height and the stairway being L-shaped, with a 5-foot square landing halfway down each flight, and the distance from the bottom of one floor’s stairway to the top of the next stairway down being 8-10 feet: 60 seconds;
(4) Time for Oswald to walk the 25 feet from the bottom of the stairs on the second floor through the vestibule (including opening the door) to the lunchroom: 8 seconds.*
My calculation comes to a total time of 123 seconds (2 minutes)—significantly longer than the Commission determined it took for the police officer to reach the second floor. Conclusion: Oswald was not on the sixth floor at the time of the shooting (the last time anyone saw Oswald on the sixth floor was at 11:55 AM—35 minutes before the first shot was fired (WCR, p. 143)). Seems to me even a mediocre lawyer could have gotten Oswald acquitted, had he lived.**
To get back to the original mystery which sparked my speculations, how did the assassin descend from the sniper’s nest and leave the Depository without detection? My best guess is he was disguised as a policeman, possibly was a real policeman. Once the sniper’s nest had been discovered, the sixth floor swarmed with officers from various agencies who didn’t know each other—the Dallas Police Department, the Sheriff’s office, the FBI, et al. An anonymous patrolman would go unnoticed amongst the throng of uniformed police (I now believe Oswald’s rifle was probably used in the shooting, which would have saved the assassin the difficulty of getting away from the crime scene carrying his own rifle).
If you are determined to solve the mystery, your task is to go through the voluminous collection of photographs of officers in and outside the Depository and figure out which one didn’t belong there. For my part, I give up. I now believe the question “Who shot JFK?” is one of those mysteries scholars and amateurs will debate for centuries with no new evidence to support one theory or the other, much like the question “Did Jesus rise from the dead?”, a debate which has been going on for 2000 years and can only be resolved by a Second Coming.***
————————————
* The FBI produced a video in which they showed how they tested the time it took Oswald to descend to the second floor: https://youtu.be/pRiOTr2J9iM (test reenactment starts at the 21:00 mark). Note how casually Agent Howlett saunters from the sniper’s nest in the SE corner to the stairwell at the NW corner. At that pace, it takes him over a minute to reach the stairs; in my “reenactment”, I grant Oswald would have walked faster, coming up with a time of 45 seconds to reach the stairs. Consider that Howlett looks like he’s about 6 feet tall, whereas Oswald was 5 foot 9 (the taller a walker, the longer the stride, the greater the speed, ceteris paribus). Also, the stick Howlett carries is considerably lighter than rifle Oswald was burdened with. Look at how conveniently located is the place where Howlett stashes the gun, versus the actual location deep in the boxes:
(WCR, Vol. XVII, p. 501)
The FBI video only shows Howlett starting down the stairs with no indication how long it took him to reach the second floor. The total time the Commission came up with for the entire route was 1 minute and 18 seconds—versus my 2 minutes (WCR, p. 152.) Do you find their test convincing?
** Hiding the rifle would have been a top priority for Oswald as it was the prime evidence linking him to the assassination. Seems like he would have pre-arranged a better hiding place (perhaps inside a box) than where it was found, especially a spot not in the most transited area on the floor, near the stairwell and the elevators.
(For some reason, the Commission has the Depository being a rectangle with unequal sides. In fact, it is a square building with 100-foot sides.)
*** I am still ready to commit myself on one question, “Who was behind the assassination?” Given Oswald’s portraying himself as a leader of the Fair Play for Cuba organization, I believe anti-Castro Cubans were the conspiracists, their hope being that Castro would be blamed for killing JFK, provoking a devastating response from the US, perhaps an invasion of the island. I’m less certain as to the role played by anti-Castro elements at the top echelon of our foreign policy establishment (such as Allen Dulles, the CIA Director fired by Kennedy after the Bay of Pigs fiasco). Whether they had knowledge of the plot, acquiesced in it, or actively supported it, remains, for me, an open question, perhaps to be answered only if all the documents concerning the assassination are ever released. Whatever the case, the military/industrial complexers must have been delighted by the dastardly deed and enthusiastically supported the belief that Castro’s Cuba was behind it; then, that having failed, equally ardent in striving to conceal the true conspiracists, their political allies.
The Washington Post’s not quite du jour but reliably de la semaine Holocaust-related article for this week is a book review of a little-known, recently republished memoir by a Hungarian Jew who spent the last year of World War II in Auschwitz. The book is Cold Crematorium by József Debreczeni; the reviewer is a professor emeritus of comparative literature at Harvard (where else?) with the intriguing name “Susan Rubin Suleiman”.
Ms. Suleiman begins her piece by lauding others who penned autobiographical memoirs of their time in German camps, including the Patron Saint of Holocaust Horrors, Elie Weisel (appropriately pronounced “weasel”). I wonder if she is aware that Weisel, in his seminal contribution to Holocaust hysteriography, Night, makes no mention of gas chambers at Auschwitz (Nor does Debreczenci apparently, as Suleiman does not mention it and she surely would). She goes on to laud Claude Lanzman for his nine-hour, unintentionally comedic documentary, Shoah (another name for the Holocaust), which features Abraham Bomba, “The Barber of Treblinka”, who recounts how he and other hairstylists gave the condemned a last haircut in the gas chamber (!) without mentioning to them (even close relatives) that they were about to become a statistic. On a tight schedule there being so many customers in line, the whole process of cutting the hair, barbers withdrawing, victims gassed, bodies removed, barbers returning, next batch let in was repeated every 15 minutes, according to Bomba. You might think I’m grasping at straws, literally, offering up an outlandish straw man who is obviously either delusional or a liar, but Bomba is featured on the website of the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC.
Our dual-Abrahamic reviewer encourages us to read Debreczeni’s reminiscences despite the plethora of similar tomes already out there, as it still has “the power to shock as well as enlighten”. True enough, if read properly, but in this case what is most enlightening is Suzy Jewzy Muezzly’s review. She relates that Debreczeni spent the last six months of the war in a hospital camp “where sick and dying prisoners were sent”. A hospital for those who were to be exterminated? Not exactly the classic Holocaust narrative. She attributes Debreczeni’s survival to the fact the Nazi’s had earlier dismantled the gas chambers “to hide evidence of their crime”. Who needs gas chambers to exterminate? A bullet to the head would suffice and be quicker and cheaper. Speaking of hiding the evidence, Suleiman unsurprisingly hides the evidence the Nazis worried about future prosecution as there is no such evidence. In fact, one purported gas chamber (with wall-to-wall windows!) was still intact when the camp it was in was liberated (as was the gas chamber at Dachau, if you believe that post-liberation construction shown to gullible tourists was actually built by the Nazis).
Suleiman can’t resist tossing in her own horrified aside: “The Nazis dehumanized inmates in their camps by assigning them numbers, obliterating their names.” Oh, the inhumanity! Is our ex-scholar so senile in her twilight years (she’s 84) that she’s unaware of the practice of assigning a number to inmates in our prisons, which becomes their primary form of identification? At least she’s not delusional, just out of touch with the real world.
Despite Suleiman’s horrified asides, the value of Debreczenci’s work peeks through. She pays a probably unintended compliment to his honesty when she admits that, according to him, inmates “died there in great numbers from starvation and illness.” What with Germany’s young men being slaughtered in their millions, its cities reduced to rubble, and its transportation infrastructure bombed to smithereens, nothing surprising there. This is the true story of the Holocaust, not women and children being sent off to be gassed upon arrival at a camp (a la Sophie’s Choice).
Debreczenci also offers enlightenment when he describes the “brutishly cruel” treatment some Jews, those chosen by the Nazis to be “kapos” responsible for keeping the inmates in line, handed out to their fellow inmates. “The best slave driver,” Debreczenci opines, “is a slave accorded a privileged position.” Not all the dead are to be mourned nor all survivors to be honored. For his perceptive insights into human behavior under the worst circumstances, I am tempted to read Cold Crematorium for myself.
——————————–
* For those of you who are not familiar with the so-called Holocaust deniers’ argument (which is probably most all of you since they’re banned from speaking in public fora), I’ll introduce you to it. But first let me make my own confession of faith: I believe that during the Second World War masses of Jews were uprooted from their homes and confined in camps where they died in droves. If you think that absolves me of the charge of being a Holocaust denier, you’d be wrong.
There are three key points on which Holocaust believers and skeptics differ: (1) How many Jews died; (2) Was the Final Solution an extermination or deportation plan; and (3) Were there genocidal gas chambers. On the first point, I do not take a position. We all know about the canonical 6 million, but I’ve seen estimates ranging as high as 12 million and as low as several hundred thousand. Whatever the true count, I do think historians should be free to come up with their best estimate without fear of being imprisoned if they come up with too low a number (as happens in Europe). On the second point, I go with the deportation option. The Nazis talked openly about a Final Solution, but always meaning the forced deportation of Jews to make Europe Judenrein. There’s no evidence that that plan ever morphed into an extermination plan. And finally, I adamantly maintain there were no genocidaI gas chambers, but you’d have to read my other postings on the subject (8, 38, 43, 89) to begin to understand why I make that claim.
For over a hundred years, ever since the United States gained a quasi-empire (Philippines, Guam, et al.) when it defeated Spain in 1898, the dominant naval power in the western Pacific has been the United States. Is the US willing to relinquish that title as things change in that part of the world? A disturbing announcement by the Pentagon, that it is going to restore the airfield on Tinian Island—the field from which the Enola Gay took off on its way to drop the bomb on Hiroshima—suggests we are not. You can bet the Chinese see it that way.
Our strategic move is motivated by the challenge from the ever expanding, ever more potent Chinese navy, particularly in light of China’s claims to disputed islands in the South China Sea. To judge whether those disputes will be resolved peacefully or not, it is enlightening to review the history of how the US gained possession of some strategic islands in the Pacific. To do so, we have to go back to 1856 when Congress passed the Guano Islands Act. The act authorized any American captain who stumbled on an uninhabited, unclaimed island covered in guano (bird-droppings) to claim it in the name of the United States (There were still islands being discovered that late). Once an island had been denuded of its deposit of avian-poop fertilizer, we lost interest in it and nobody else showed much interest in claiming it, either.
Then came the Air Age and waystations for planes to refuel on the long flight across the vast Pacific became vital. The competition over any insular terra firma big enough to support a landing strip was on. The older imperial powers–Britain, France, and the imperial upstart Japan—already possessed most of the major islands (The Solomons, Tahiti, Okinawa, etc.) and we had Hawaii, but smaller islands to which no one had clear title were up for grabs. The Europeans competed with us over some of the islands, but the competitor we most feared was a rising Japan (and we all know what that competition led to!).
The tactics used in gaining possession of an island back then mirrors what is taking place in the South China Sea today. For instance, in 1935 we landed some Hawaiian Islanders (in the dead of night and telling no one) on three uninhabited, on three mid-Pacific islands to which both we and the British laid tenuous claim. After a year of surreptitious colonizing, President Roosevelt revealed the sneaky scheme and proclaimed the islands American territory.
A corollary to the military aspect of island acquisition is the economic aspect. A country can claim an Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) out to 200 miles off its coast, but the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) makes a distinction between “islands”, which can support human habitation, and “rocks”, which cannot. An EEZ can only be claimed around an island, not a rock.
This distinction has not stopped Japan from claiming an EEZ around Okinotorishima, a rocky outcrop hundreds of miles from its shores.
China, South Korea, and Taiwan contest Japan’s claim; and, if oil is ever discovered there, you can bet we will, too. It might even move us to sign on to UNCLOS, something we have so far refused to do (while we justify our meddling in disputes in the South China Sea as in support of international law!).
The distinction between a rock and an island probably explains our refusal to ratify UNCLIOS. Were we to do so, we could be taken to court for claiming EEZs around what are clearly rocks, including many of the guano islands we found useful in World War II but have since abandoned (causing them to revert to their original state: uninhabited). There’s even a reef in the Hawaiian Islands chain we claim an EEZ around which is entirely under water at low tide! Joining UNCLOS would also open us up to the sort of disputes roiling the waters of the South China Sea, as several of our islands are claimed by other countries, including another island of WW II fame, Wake Island (claimed by the Marshall Islands).
Our restoration of Tinian Island’s runway is a worrisome sign of our unwillingness to recognize and accept that the world is a changing place and that, unlike the case of Israel, no divine being has ordained our possession in perpetuity of some part of the earth’s surface, in our case a salty, wet part. The peace-loving people in both China and the USA have no wish to go to war against each other. Yet, our talking heads, both military and civilian, glibly talk about a coming war as if it is inevitable. To put it nicely, this tiny fraction of our population, who have the fate of us all in their hands, have things blown way out of proportion. Can’t they foresee what their loose talk could lead to? Are they unable to picture what such a war would be like? It’s not like the old days where two armies battled in some field and not even nearby villages were harmed. In today’s world, the death and destruction from a war with China—or any nuclear power—would be of such awful magnitude it would be hard to tell the victor from the vanquished.
War with China is not inevitable if the US is willing to relinquish its historic role as the dominant naval power in the western Pacific. Then, level-headed, intelligent men of goodwill could arrive at a compromise, as the European powers did at the Berlin Conference of 1884-45 when they divvied up Africa into “spheres of influence” (perhaps not the most high-minded example, but an example nonetheless). For instance, it might be agreed that China or a consortium of the countries whose shores are lapped by the waters of the Pacific would assume responsibility in the western Pacific for guaranteeing that all countries abide by the Convention on the Law of the Sea, while the United States assumed the same role in the eastern Pacific.
If, on the other hand, our hawkish foreign policy mavens, with their constant prattle about China gaining on the US militarily, prove unbending, implying the cardinal tenet of their strategic thinking is “You have to do it to them before they do it to you”, it will have disastrous consequences. If we do not challenge their fatalism (a double entendre), the last plane ever to depart from Tinian Island, or any island, will carry a payload that makes the one in the bomb bay of the Enola Gay look like a firecracker.